By Harmony Tenney, MBA
Radio has been asking its clients the wrong question: “Did it work?” When the bottom line looks flat, everyone decides radio can’t be measured and walks away.
What we need to be asking is:
“How much new customer revenue (and how many new customers) did the campaign bring in?”
I learned that the hard way.
A local tree care company asked me to present a proposal to their president. Ninety minutes later, after I had answered every question he could think of, they signed an $18,000 annual agreement. I guaranteed a minimum 5% increase in revenue.
The campaign ran smoothly. We met every month. They gave me their seasonal themes: Summer Storm Repair, Fall Feeding, and Evaluating Tree Health. They loved their ads. By everything I could see and hear, they were happy.
Then renewal time came, and they hesitated to meet. When I probed, they told me revenue hadn’t increased. At all. Same dollar amount as the year before. They brushed me off. Hard.
Instead of walking away in silence, my in-house contact and I went looking for what occurred. The first problem:
- They hadn’t tracked monthly customer counts.
- They hadn’t tracked new customer revenue.
The only number anyone was watching was the bottom line.
My contact generously helped me dig through the records the hard way. And there it was: one of their largest commercial accounts, worth about $100,000 a year, had switched to another vendor during the campaign!
When we separated new customers from existing ones, the picture changed completely. Radio had brought in about $100,000 in new client revenue, enough to replace that account. For every dollar invested, they attracted about $5.56 in new business!
Flat wasn’t failure. Flat was proof radio could hold the line while their biggest customer walked out the door. They hadn’t taken a loss. Radio kept them afloat.
They didn’t renew. By the time we had the proof, I couldn’t get another appointment. The decision was made the day they looked at the bottom line and stopped.
A business owner’s total revenue is the sum of dozens of factors: the weather, staffing, a new competitor, a big customer leaving. Advertising is only one input. Judge a campaign by revenue alone, and radio becomes the fall guy. Not anymore.
In my client’s case, measuring new customer numbers from the start would have saved the account. Ask the right question up front, and those numbers add up month by month.
Dig deeper. Work the math. Get credit for what you grow.
Harmony Tenney, MBA, author of The Ultimate Radio Sales Playbook, is dedicated to connecting communities through radio’s superpowers. Radio Ink twice named her a Top Ten U.S. Radio Marketing Consultant. Reach her at Harmony@UltimateRadioSales.comor UltimateRadioSales.com.
